Nabeel Basheer

The Kindest Way to Lose Someone

There is a kind of room you learn to recognise.

Nobody in it is quite sitting, and nobody is quite standing. The tea goes cold because nobody remembers they made it. Someone is in pain on the bed, and everyone else is in a different kind of pain around it. And all of them, the one on the bed included, are waiting. Not for a doctor. Not for news. For the thing that could come tonight, or next week, or while you have stepped out for a minute.

I spent more time in rooms like that than I expected to when I was young. Friends. Family. Different hospitals, different years. The same room.

Somebody once said that of all the ways to lose a person, death is the kindest. I did not feel kindness in those rooms.

So when Richard Smith wrote that dying of cancer is the best death, I was furious. And it was worse because I had met him. He came to St John’s in Bangalore when he was the editor of the BMJ, and he was one of the kindest people I have met in a hospital. Attentive. Unhurried. No performance. And now this kind man was telling me that the room I knew was the good one.

His reasoning was simple. Every other way to die takes something from you. Sudden death takes the goodbye. Dementia takes the person and leaves the body. Cancer is the one that gives you time. His prescription for that time was “love, morphine, and whisky.”

It took me ten years to admit he was right.

I have since watched dementia keep someone’s body in the room long after they had left it. I have seen a sudden death leave a family holding a sentence that will never be finished. Next to those, the waiting in my room was a strange sort of gift. At least everyone knew. At least there was time to say something.

But the waiting only becomes a gift if the pain is taken care of. That is what the morphine is for. And that is where my anger went.

Love, morphine and whisky is easy to prescribe in a country where all three can be arranged. In India, fewer than two in a hundred people who need palliative care get any. In the year Smith wrote his essay, the whole country used enough morphine for perhaps 40,000 people. In a country of 1.3 billion.

So in most of India, the room I remember is not the exception. It is the rule. The waiting, and the pain, with nobody coming.

Except here.

I have the huge privilege of living in Kerala, the one state where a good death is not a fantasy. I have stood in one of those houses when the volunteers arrived. I also know them the way most of us know things now, from what I read and from reels. Ordinary people carrying a bag of medicines, sitting on the edge of the bed, asking about the pain before anything else. For decades they have gone from house to house, until this small state ended up holding most of the country’s palliative care.

I think about my room when I watch them. The same waiting. The same cold tea. But somebody has come.

Maybe that is what the line really means. Death is not the kind part. The kind part is who is in the room when it comes.

peoplepersonal

Back to writings